Thanks Willpower
I have checked and fitted extra rivets to the undertray without success. This week I found the push in top radiator mounting clamps were worn so the top of the radiator was moving about a bit. Took them off lined with sticky back foam (2mm) and refitted and that fixed that. Cannot reach the bottom ones to check as I need to remover the undertray again, so a job for Sunday.
I checked recall service bulletins and checked those but all okay. Everyone who gets in the car points in a different direction when I ask "where do you think that noise is coming from" I still think low front so the radiator is definitely the next thing to check.
I have watched a video on Youtube on how to remove the front bumper to look behind that and check its fixings but despite looking easy I am thinking that's a bit drastic. I just wish I could induce the noise while the car is on the ramps, as no amount of tapping around the front is producing it. So fix something take it for a drive, luckily a road nearby has noise inducing faults, fix it again and ......
I love my CX-5 but this problem is proving frustrating.